Nick Schenk

A lot of places in Sandusky are built for a summer weekend. The Inn at 201 Fulton was built for the rest of the year too.

A downtown corner, rebuilt from the studs

The Inn is on the corner of Fulton and West Market Streets, near Sandusky’s central fire station. The Aldridge family took it on as a full top-to-bottom renovation. Corey and Morgan Aldridge, who own Aldridge Restoration, did the project with Corey’s dad, Jamie, and it took close to two years. It had its soft opening in April 2024, the same week as the total solar eclipse.

The interiors were designed by MW Design Studio here in Sandusky, and it shows. Everything is new.

We manage the Inn for the Aldridges, and it’s one of the places we like showing people the most.

Eight suites, each with a kitchen

  • Four two-bedroom suites that sleep up to eight.
  • Four one-bedroom suites that sleep up to four.

Every suite has its own full kitchen and bathroom, new appliances and smart TVs. The shared balconies look out over Sandusky Bay and the downtown rooftops.

One night, or 270

This is the part that makes the Inn different. It’s licensed for stays of up to 270 nights in a row, which almost nothing else in the area can offer. That makes it a good fit for:

  • Traveling nurses and medical staff on a contract.
  • Contractors and work crews on a long job.
  • People between homes who are relocating, renovating or building.
  • Anyone who wants Sandusky in the off-season, when it’s quieter and easier to book.

You still get a real downtown address. Restaurants, the waterfront and the Jet Express are all a short walk away, and Cedar Point is a quick drive.

Thinking about a longer stay?

Send us a note at [email protected] with your dates and how many people, and we’ll tell you what’s open.

Email us about a longer stay →

Every property management company says they’re full-service. We get it. We hear it from owners all the time, usually right after they tell us what their last company didn’t do.

So here’s what it actually means when we take over a property.

We run hotels, not just listings

This is the part that makes us different. We run island resorts, boutique inns, a motel and whole apartment buildings every night. Front desk, housekeeping, maintenance, food and beverage, rental fleets. Our own people do the work.

Before Ohio Shores, we both spent years as resort directors at Cedar Fair, so we’ve seen how a big operation runs and what it takes to keep guests coming back. Your property gets run the same way.

What we handle

  • Guests, start to finish. Messaging, check-in, problems at 11 p.m. and reviews.
  • Housekeeping and maintenance. Our teams, our standards and our inspections.
  • Pricing and distribution. We set rates every day and list your property across the big booking channels, not just one.
  • Back office. Accounting, owner statements and taxes collected and paid the right way.

You can see everything

Owners get a portal with their calendar, reservations and statements. You don’t have to email us to find out how your month went. You can look.

We’re owners too

We own and operate some of these properties ourselves, and we invest in real estate on the side. That’s where we test new pricing and systems before they ever touch your property. We’d rather learn the expensive lessons on our own places.

Who we’re a fit for

Hotels and resorts that want someone to run the whole operation. Apartment buildings that want to fill units with short and mid-term stays. And homeowners who want their place to make money without becoming their second job.

If any of that is you, take a look at how we work with owners and send us a note. You’ll talk to one of us, not a call center.

Ask anyone who works up here and they’ll tell you the same thing. Summer is great, but September is when the lake is at its best.

Fall: the good stuff, fewer people

The water is still warm into September, the crowds thin out after Labor Day, and you can actually get a table at dinner. The towns along the shore stay open, and the drives along the lake are hard to beat when the trees turn.

Then there’s Cedar Point’s HalloWeekends, which takes over the park on fall weekends with haunted mazes and Halloween events. It’s a whole different crowd from summer, and plenty of people plan their whole year around it. If that’s your thing, book early, because those weekends fill up.

Winter: yes, really

Sandusky doesn’t shut down in winter. It has two big indoor waterpark resorts, Great Wolf Lodge and Kalahari, so a January weekend can still mean swimsuits. A lot of families stay with us and spend the day at the waterpark, then come back to a whole house with a kitchen and room to spread out.

And if you’ve never seen Lake Erie in the winter, with the ice along the shore and the quiet towns, it’s worth a trip just for that. Bring a good coat.

Why the off-season is a smart time to book

  • Better availability. The big group homes that book a year out for July are often open in October.
  • Easier weekends. Less traffic, shorter lines, quieter beaches.
  • Same homes, same team. We’re here all year, so you get the same service in November that you’d get in July.

Some things do slow down. The island ferries run a lighter schedule in the fall and can stop once the lake freezes, and some seasonal spots close for the winter. Check before you go.

Ready to look? Here are all of our Ohio rentals, and our trip guide covers each town.

This is probably the question we answer most: how do we get to the islands? The short answer is a ferry. The longer answer depends on where you’re starting and whether you’re bringing the car.

The three boats people use

Jet Express. Passenger-only and fast. It runs out of downtown Sandusky (and Port Clinton) to Kelleys Island and Put-in-Bay during the season. If you’re staying in Sandusky and you don’t need a car on the island, this is the easy one. You walk on downtown and you’re on an island not long after.

Miller Ferry. Leaves from Catawba Island and goes to Put-in-Bay. It takes cars, which matters if you’re hauling a lot of stuff or staying on the island for a few days.

Kelleys Island Ferry. Leaves from Marblehead and goes to Kelleys Island. It also takes cars.

Schedules change by season, and the boats run a lighter schedule in spring and fall. Always check the ferry’s own website the week you go. We’d rather you double-check than get stuck at a dock.

Day trip or stay over?

Plenty of our guests stay on the mainland and do the islands as a day trip. It works well, especially with a big group in one of our Sandusky homes. Ride out in the morning, rent a golf cart, eat lunch on the water, and come back for dinner.

But a night on the island is a different trip. The day-trippers leave, it gets quiet, and you get the sunset to yourself. If that sounds like you:

Our honest tips

  • Get a golf cart. Both islands are made for them. Reserve ahead on summer weekends.
  • Watch the last boat time. Every summer someone in a group chat finds out the hard way.
  • Go midweek if you can. Saturday on Put-in-Bay is a party. Tuesday is a vacation.

Our trip guide has the ferry links and island info all in one spot.

Every spring we get the same kind of call. A coach, a parent or a team mom, looking for one place that fits the whole roster for tournament weekend. Most rentals can’t do it. The Attic can.

Where the name comes from

The Attic sits on Cleveland Road in Sandusky, upstairs from the Opfer family’s business, S & H Blinds & Floors. That’s the whole joke: it really is the attic.

Ed Opfer built it about 30 years ago as a home for his family, right above the business, so he could see the kids off to school and be around for lunch. Once the kids were grown, Ed and his wife Julie moved down the street, and the next generation, Clare and Corey Opfer, turned the space into a 4,400-square-foot lodge. It opened in 2023, and Ed was part of the decisions the whole way through. The family wanted it to feel cozy and a little eclectic, and it does. Old photos of Sandusky line the walls.

We’re proud to manage it for them.

What’s inside

Six bedrooms, 13 beds and three bathrooms, with room for up to 28 guests. There’s an open chef’s kitchen, a big dining and living area, laundry, a game room, a multi-level deck and a hot tub.

The bedrooms are set up for groups on purpose. There’s a mix of queens, doubles, twins and bunks, so the coaches get one room and a pile of twelve-year-olds get another, and nobody ends up on the floor.

Who it works for

It’s directly across the street from the Cedar Point Sports Center and a few minutes from Sports Force Parks, so tournament mornings are a walk, not a convoy. Sports teams are the obvious fit. We also see family reunions, bridal and baby showers, church retreats and work groups. Basically anyone who’s tired of splitting a group across three hotel floors and never actually seeing each other.

Why one house beats a block of rooms

  • Everyone is in one place. Team dinner happens at one table, not in a hotel lobby.
  • You have a real kitchen. Feeding 25 people at restaurants three times a day adds up fast.
  • The parents get a break. The kids are in the next room, not two floors away.

A couple of tips

Tournament weekends book early, sometimes a season ahead. If you know your dates, grab them. And if your group is bigger than 28, ask us. We have other homes in Sandusky and can usually keep everyone close.

See photos and book at theatticsandusky.com, or browse all of our Sandusky homes.

See photos and book The Attic →